Show VIP pricing first. Make the non-member price feel like a penalty.
Broken down by Jonas, a former Meta growth lead, from Fabletics's live ads in the Meta Ad LibraryFabletics leads every ad with 'VIP member price: $24.99' (regular: $54.95). The membership isn't an upsell, it's the default frame. This inverts the typical subscription pitch. Instead of 'buy the product, and also consider subscribing,' it's 'members get this price, non-members pay 2x.' The psychology flips: not subscribing feels like overpaying, not 'not subscribing' feels like saving. The membership becomes the obvious choice because the alternative is visibly worse.
Membership anchoring works for any subscription model, coffee subscriptions, software, box services, content platforms. The tactic: always show the member price as the default, with the non-member price as the penalty. Never position the subscription as 'extra', position it as 'the normal way people buy this.' Most subscription businesses make the opposite mistake: they sell the product first and pitch the subscription as an afterthought. Flip it.
This breakdown is built from Fabletics's active ads, running for 9+ weeks at the time of writing, a signal the format is still working. See the current set for yourself in Meta's public Ad Library.